The Rebel Club

"Don’t be fooled by this summer of AI hype" by Timnit Gebru & Emily M. Bender

These kinds of post will give you a starting point for sharing thought-provoking and critical content in various environments (like in a #random Slack channel at your workplace).

Read

https://www.technologyreview.com/2026/09/22/1144867/dont-be-fooled-summer-ai-hype/

Share

Quotes

In all these incidents, massive fanfare from the companies (presented as mea culpas in illicit hacking cases) is accompanied by intense press coverage. Once there is time for experts in the relevant fields to examine what happened, a very different story emerges, but one that gets less media attention.


Claims of incipient, dangerous superintelligence are not based in good scientific or engineering practice. Rather, they are narratives based in ideologies of transhumanism, eugenics, and wishful thinking about imagined future digital humans.


We know better than to make decisions based on marketing and better than to capitulate to corporate pressure to make those decisions quickly. Wise decision-making, by policymakers and communities, demands time to hear from independent experts and contextualize corporate claims. The best possible outcome from this summer of hype is that policymakers and the public at large learn to take a breath, hold onto our skepticism, and recognize this kind of hype for what it is the next time it comes around.

Reactions

Two instances of the NoAI emoji (moominpappa).

#share